Indian Hill mansion hearth: New court docs expose heated struggle be


It’s been more than a few many years given that an Indian Hill mansion burned to the floor, but the authorized drama surrounding the hearth continues to smolder. 

Hundreds of documents submitted in federal court expose new data surrounding a civil lawsuit involving the homeowners of the $four million dwelling and their insurance policies enterprise.

Jeffrey and Maria Decker say Chubb Nationwide Insurance failed to honor the couple’s assert immediately after the 2014 hearth. The insurance provider statements Jeffrey and Maria concealed and misrepresented info.

Courtroom documents expose new evidence and insight into the insurance policies company’s investigation – a portion of which focuses on Jeffrey’s whereabouts in the 70 minutes major up to the hearth.

Chubb claims Decker had claimed to be miles absent at a Blue Ash construction web-site when the hearth broke out. On the other hand, the company’s internal investigation allegedly displays mobile cell phone information positioned Jeffrey at or all-around his dwelling 16 minutes ahead of the to start with 911 connect with about the hearth.

By no means-ahead of-witnessed surveillance images exhibit Jeffrey at the Madeira Walgreens soon ahead of the hearth. Decker claimed he was at the shop to obtain cough drops, according to a transcript of his recorded job interview with a Chubb agent.

Decker acquired of the hearth when spending for the cough drops, he claimed. His spouse known as him to split the information.

He compensated dollars and remaining the shop.

The insurance policies enterprise statements the online video displays Decker leaving one hundred ten seconds later on with “no cough drop deal visible in his arms.”

In a separate filing, the Decker’s attorney admits it can be him in the shop, but denies Chubb’s characterization that he lied about shopping for the product.

Although cough drops may perhaps not seem to be important, Chubb statements it can be element of Decker’s alleged trail of lies.

[SLIDESHOW: By no means-ahead of-witnessed shots exhibit aftermath of Indian Hill mansion hearth]

In a new filing, the Decker’s attorney wrote their skilled located connect with information can only area a person inside a 21.75 mile radius of a mobile tower, which signifies Decker could have been at the Blue Ash task web-site.

Another bombshell uncovered in the documents exhibit Chubb investigators assert the hearth started in the kitchen area.

Fire scene shots in the investigative report exhibit the mangled metal of what was the moment alleged kitchen area appliances.

The Decker’s attorneys countered that assert, expressing the destruction from the hearth was so important, that, for that reason, there is no evidence to pinpoint just where the hearth started.

Investigators went on to compose the hearth was not caused by electrical, mechanical, temperature troubles, smoking cigarettes or cooking. They feel the hearth was intentionally set.

On the other hand, Decker’s attorney wrote that Chubb’s own investigators admitted they have been restricted mainly because of the destruction and samples taken from the dwelling examined damaging for accelerants.

Chubb’s investigators assert accelerants could have been there, just not in these samples.

As for the formal investigation into the hearth, in April of 2015, the Condition Fire Marshal informed FOX19 NOW the lead to was undetermined, but the investigation remained open up.

This week, we have been informed the business didn’t “have time” for an job interview on the situation but, there was practically nothing new to report. On the other hand, in a motion to avert the state’s investigation from becoming disclosed in civil court, the Fire Marshal argued disclosure would “generate a superior probability of disclosing the identity of an uncharged suspect.”

The judge agreed, so it stays unclear the variety of evidence that has not been publicly unveiled.

The court information also exhibit Decker known as the Indian Hill Rangers a person month ahead of the hearth to report a threatening cell phone connect with.

Decker informed police “It spooked the [expletive] out of me.”

According to court documents, Decker claimed his spouse traced the number to Cincinnati Reds Corridor of Famer Chris Sabo. Decker informed police he and Sabo both of those belonged to the Kenwood State Club.

He also claimed he and his spouse drove to Sabo’s dwelling a confrontation ensued. Sabo denied acquiring manufactured the connect with and knew practically nothing about it. The transcript reads the Deckers knowledgeable Indian Hill Rangers about the incident.

FOX19 NOW has been unable to get to Sabo for remark.

Courtroom documents exhibit Decker later on claimed in a deposition the connect with was traced to a pay cell phone at a advantage shop.

Our phone calls to the Deckers’ attorney have not been returned.

A spokesperson for Chubb Nationwide Insurance Firm informed FOX19 NOW they really don’t remark on pending litigation.

The jury demo is set to start off this summer months.

Copyright 2017 WXIX. All rights reserved. 

Leave a Reply